Friday, October 5, 2012

Tone and Mood in Literature - Moving Beyond Paragraphs

I slammed my hand down on the desk.

"What are you doing?" I bellowed.

Frozen, terrified students stared at me, looked at their classmates and back to me.  Shock swallowed their breath and turned every fiber of attention to me, the psychotic teacher, standing in the middle of the room.

I stood up, waited another moment and then asked, "How did my tone affect your mood?"

A collective sigh lifted the tension, numerous hands went to chests and a few "Oh my Gods" slipped into the growing murmur of relief.

That's how we started talking about the concept of tone and mood.  The key idea being that an author's tone can affect your mood.  Often times students confuse the two ideas because they are so closely related so I wanted a concrete, shared experience that we could all refer to if there was any confusion between tone and mood.

That was about two weeks ago.  The students still talk about my tone that day.  They laugh about it now, though I still notice a hint of nervousness in their chuckles.

Students in sixth grade have to analyze pieces of literature for the tone the author used in a particular piece of writing.  It is a skill that is often tested on our state assessment, as I am sure it is in other states.  Also, in seventh grade, students have to be able to create well written responses to prompts using text evidence to support their viewpoint.

This has been a difficult concept for me to teach in the past.  This year I mashed together a continuum of lessons that builds towards those ideas.  So far I am very happy with the results.  Of course it all started with a very concrete understanding.

Analysis of Art - Transmediation

To help children develop their creativity I look for ways to blend my content with other disciplines. With the internet it has become easy to share the art work of great artists with my students. Which makes it much easier to begin the process of transmediation, the process of recreating meaning of a text from one medium to another. In these lessons students will recreate meaning from a painting by observing, interpreting and creating their own art interpretations that display the tone of a written piece of text.

As with any new process, we have to scaffold the learning. My goal is not so much to teach them how to analyze for tone (important ELA skills) but to develop the universal process of observe, interpret and create. There are many beautiful pictures that lead wonderful discussion like these ones from Winslow Homer painted in the late 1890's.
The Gulf Stream, Winslow Homer, 1899, oil

After the Hurricane, Winslow Homer, 1899

A great way to get started is with this lesson idea from which introduces the students to the ideas of finding implicit and explicit details in art. 

Portrait of Dr. Gachet, Vincent Van Gogh, 1890

Students observe the portrait and interpret how Dr. Gachet is feeling.  His feeling, or the tone of the piece, is an implicit detail, the evidence to support that thinking are the explicit details.  The students often say that Dr. Gachet is sad.  The tone of the portrait is sadness.  That is an implicit detail, the students have inferred or interpreted that he is feeling sad based on their observations.  Then the students have to find the explicit evidence to prove that he is sad:  his frown, the dark colors, the hand on his face, his droopy eyes.

When students are finished they can begin to compose or create a short paragraph to describe the tone of the painting.  The implicit detail is the topic sentence.  The explicit details are the supporting sentences.  Very structured, well-thought out and meets the goals of our state learning objectives.  But with my students I wanted to continue to go deeper with the idea and to also show them that a well written paragraph is not always the end all be all of our class.

Analysis of Tones in Videogames

Motivating students often comes form tying into their interests.  Looking at outstanding art has its place, students need to be exposed to the work of the master artists.  But looking at still pictures can only hold their attention for so long.  (I wrote about keeping students attention in this blog post last year) So the next level of tone analysis tapped into their love of videogames, it could also include movie trailers as well.

The lesson comes from and requires students to watch video game trailers and analyze the tone of the trailer.

Using what the students learned from analyzing art, they watch the videos two or three times, use their tone word list to identify a suitable tone (implicit detail) and then find three explicit details from the video to support their thinking.

The Limbo preview leaves much more of an impact on them than Little Big Planet 2.  Some students will begin to put their hands over their ears when the musical dissonance increases towards the middle of the clip. Ori and the Blind Forest can be broken into segments, allowing students to analyze how the tone of a piece of text can change as the story progresses.

There is a high level of engagement when students are watching these previews and it is easy for them to remember their writing lessons from Dr. Gachet:  implicit is the topic sentence and explicit is the supporting sentences.

Analysis of Tone in Literature

The next piece was to take the concepts of tone and analyze written work; at least that is what the state wants us to do.  

Until now the students had been practicing in their notebooks with me walking around, spot checking their work.  I wanted a  quick way to gather data on their writing without taking home 140 sheets of paper. 

Thank you Google Forms.  I created a form and embedded it on my class website.  The form begins with a quick review of the concept of tone.  Then students read a short paragraph and write a well-formatted paragraph explaining their perspective on the tone of the paragraph.

When the students submit their form I get a spreadsheet that looks like this:

Now I can quickly assess how my students are doing with the concepts of tone and explicit and implicit details.

But like I said earlier, I do not want well structured paragraph writing to be the highest pinnacle of academic achievement in my room.  So enter one last piece to the puzzle:  humumet.  A concept I discovered while reading a post from

Students skim The Conch Bearer for passages that display obvious tones. Students identify the tone (implicit detail), and then identify words (explicit details) on the page that could be used to create a the tone. They circle these words and then use art to edit out all the other words on the page with a picture that matches the new tone and/or narrative.

Below are examples of some of the work done in my class. I think you should be able to infer the tone based on their art and the words they chose.

My students still need more practice with writing well structured paragraphs based on analysis of an author's tone.  But I can honestly say that my students this year have a much better grasp of the difference between tone and mood and how explicit details work to explain implicit details. 

It all ties back to transmediation the process of observing, interpreting and creating.


  1. Thank you soooooo much for these lessons!!!

  2. You are very welcome. I hope that your students enjoy learning about tone and mood.

  3. This is a PHENOMENAL lesson. You obviously are an amazing teacher, and generous to boot!
    Thank you so much for posting this.

  4. Thank you. I hope it helps your students understand how to structure their writing.

  5. these really helped me thanks$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  6. Terrific ideas and gorgeous work samples, David, Thank you!

    1. Thank you for the kind words. I hope you were able to use some of these ideas.

  7. This is so thoroughly-explained and detailed, just superb. I just shared this on facebook. Thank you. I've just bookmarked your blog, and am certain that I'll be returning in the near future.

    1. Thank you for the feedback. What I have noticed about this lesson is the need to revisit throughout the school year. Multiple opportunities using many different types of media is something I would emphasize.

  8. Question: On the cited website (byrdseed) the author stated the mood was synonymous with implicit, but you associate implicit with tone. Do you feel the lesson goes over the same whether I teach implicit as tone or as mood?

    1. That is a great question. I use the lesson design for tone and it works well. Implicit of course means understood but not clearly stated. So these concepts work well when a reader has to infer a concept and then use the evidence from the text to support their opinion. Thank you for asking.

  9. This is easily the best lesson I have read on Tone Analysis. Thank you so much for sharing!

    1. Thank you very much. I hope it helps your students.

  10. With all the development associated with computer along with world wide web, quite a few completely new career alternatives opened up. Freelance publishing is certainly one of all of them. It's gain popularity owing to the numerous advantages it includes. Article marketing has become the simplest way associated with liquidating sparetime directly into dollars for many freelancers whom are not able to require a frequent career.creative writing techniques

  11. Great write-up! Writing is a talent, and it must not be wasted. As with everything that we had been entrusted, we should let it grow and share it with the world.>learner motivation

  12. AMAZING! Thank you for sharing!!!

  13. Hello! I just wish to give enormous thumbs up for the nice info you've got right here on this post. I am happy when reading your article with updated information! Thanks allot and hope that you will post more site that are related to this site.

  14. This is a fantastic website and I can not recommend you guys enough. I really appreciate your post. It is very helpful for all the people on the web.

  15. Computers themselves, and software yet to be developed, will revolutionize the way we learn.

  16. This is my first time i visit here. I found so many interesting stuff in your blog especially its discussion. From the tons of comments on your articles, I guess I am not the only one having all the enjoyment here keep up the good work